by Michelle Harrington
This article is based on interviews with the following Canaan owners who feed their Canaans a raw diet. Dionna and Robert Begg (Ontario); Cathey Dunn (Colorado); Jill Hillman (Indiana); Renee and Evan Kent (Rhode Island), Christina Miller (Australia); Larry Myers and Michelle Harrington (Ontario); Wendy and Victor Sanchez (Minnesota)
Feeding a raw diet is hardly a new concept. Well before the recent pet food recalls, there have been owners who feed their canines an alternative to commercial food products. Cathey Dunn has been feeding her dogs a raw diet for over 16 years. Although the raw diet is much more visible these days in terms of discussion, it is still viewed, for the most part, as controversial with much debate centred on the different “approaches”.
Why “Go Raw”
For some Canaan owners their decision to go raw is encouraged by the breeder of their new puppy while others are motivated by articles or books they have read. Renee and Evan Kent were in search of “ a food that agreed with all of the dogs that allowed them to maintain a healthy weight, clean teeth, and normal stool.” At that time the Kents had a dog who always had gas, greenish smelly stools, and looked thin no matter how much they fed him. In January 2001, the Kents switched to a raw diet and never looked back. Wendy and Victor Sanchez feel fortunate that they have obtained their dogs from breeders who also feed raw, “all of our dogs have been raw feed since birth.” Michelle and Larry’s Maccabee was on kibble for a year. Their decision to investigate an alternative to commercial pet food was borne from the fact of wanting his environment as natural as possible. “We had moved away from vaccinations and felt a raw diet was the next step.”
Illness has also inspired other owners to explore alternative diets for their dogs. Dionna and Robert Begg resisted the raw diet for a long while because they were afraid it was too complex. Then when “Tiffy” suffered from an autoimmune disease when she was about 2 ½ years of age, they decided to research an alternative to her diet and have been feeding her raw ever since. Chris Miller’s “Spock” was the catalyst that drew her to a natural diet:
“Spock was diagnosed with Lymphosarcoma early in his life. I wasn’t going to go the chemo therapy route, as Lymphosarcoma had a very high reoccurrence rate after treatment. I couldn’t change the diagnosis, but I could change the way I looked at a lot of my animal husbandry. This was the point that I completely changed the dogs’ diet to a raw meat based diet. I also became more firm on my stand of limited vaccinations for puppies and basically no vaccinations for adult dogs – only titer testing.”
Where does One Start?
Jill Hillman was inspired by her breeders Wendy and Victor Sanchez of MidSummer’s Canaan Dogs. Jill owns two Canaans, “Raizel” and “Shani” who thrive on a raw diet, which includes “BARF Burgers!” Working together with friends who are interested in exploring different lifestyle choices for their canines can also be very beneficial. Cathey and a group of her friends compared research and diets and purchased food together in larger quantities to reduce the cost. She like others also found inspiration in reading books, articles, and attending seminars by raw food practitioners. To further increase their knowledge, Wendy and Victor subscribed to different raw feeding groups: “As soon as we felt comfortable with the ins and outs, we began to make our own modifications.”
Different philosophies - Where do we go from here?
Some people follow the “BARF” diet by Billinghurst or other raw practitioners, like Volhard, Pitcairin, or Schultze. Not unlike humans, dogs are individuals and sensitive to certain foods. Most of the Canaan owners interviewed have followed a particular practitioner from the onset but overtime have modified the diet according to how their dogs adapt. Chris had started with the Vollhard diet, which later she modified into what worked best for her and her dogs. She prefers “a 70% meat to 30% bone ratio, but that doesn’t happen at every meal.” She also tries to implement offal at least 4 times a week into their diet, and likes to keep the meat sources as varied as possible.
Michelle and Larry’s basis was also founded on the Volhard approach. Although more complicated (i.e. more ingredients) than a BARF diet, the concept of a “complete kill” meal made sense. The ingredients are to encompass the complete feeding of a killed animal. They too have since modified the diets of their Canaans according to how they look, feel, and react throughout the seasons. “Macc had demonstrated a habit of licking his rear leg during the winter months. He also resisted eating the raw beef. A section in the Volhard book suggested that he was reluctant with the beef as it was a “cold” meat. We switched him to a “warm” meat, chicken, and he eagerly ate it all. He also stopped licking his leg. We moved back to beef when the warm weather returned.”
Wendy and Victor Sanchez’s initial approach to raw feeding was based on the BARF diet but they also introduced modifications: “Over time we realized that our style of feeding evolved so much over the years that what, and how, we fed our dogs no longer fell in line with the Billinghurst model. After some research we made a more complete transition to the Prey Model approach which more closely resembled the style of feeding that we have graduated to over the years.” Dionna and Robert continue to stick with the diet suggested in Wendy Volhard’s book, but have also made some slight adjustments such as “feeding only one meal, reducing the amount of meat, and adding pumpkin for bulk.” These adjustments were made on the advice of their veterinarian as Tiffy needed to lose significant weight that she had put on taking steroid medication when she was ill.
Renee digested several approaches and decided not to follow one specific diet: “Being bogged down in details is overwhelming for me and can certainly intimidate someone new to the diet. I just feed mostly raw meat and bone and throw in extras and veggies when I think of it or when the condition of the dog warrants it.” While being educated on the different approaches, Cathey adopted her own diet based on the concept that “your dog should eat what he/she would have eaten in the dog’s country of origin.”. She believes that one should customize the diet to the dog. Each dog is different and has different dietary needs. Some of her Akitas love fruit cantaloupe, blueberries, bing cherries, and raw eggs, while her Canaan will not touch fruit or raw eggs. However, her Canaan will gobble up the fruit if it is ground up in the meat. “My Canaan Dog can be a very picky eater, and I will often switch her from one food to another, i.e. raw beef to chicken or turkey, more frequently than I switch the Akita’s food.”
Benefits of Raw
“Softer shiny coats”, “smaller non-smelly stools”, and “clean white teeth” are the top three observations that these Canaan Dog owners notice when they implement a natural diet. Since the stools are generally much harder and more compact on a raw diet, anal gland secretion is also more effective. For many, the introduction of chicken necks and backs helps polish up teeth nicely, and picking up less poop is always a welcome reward! “Enhanced energy levels”, “improved muscle tone”, and an “overall solidness of the dog” are other notable improvements that these owners proudly admit. Michelle and Larry need their Canaans to be in top shape for herding lessons, trials, and events so overall conditioning is very important: “herding requires a well-conditioned dog to perform outruns and cover great distances in the pastures.” They maintain that the raw approach aids in stamina and overall performance – and the proof is always in the pudding!
Owners also comment on the “reduced vet visits”, “minimal shedding”, “decrease in water consumption”, and the “eagerness of the dog to eat their food”. Cathey says she witnesses her dogs having “ a contentment when finished eating.” Chris loves the fact that her dogs have “better smelling breath, larger litter size and larger puppy birth weight and just an overall better wellbeing.” Wendy and Victor are enjoying the advantages of “increased strength of immunity, and vigorous puppies.”
The Importance of Supplements
For these Canaan owners the “complete” diet consists of various supplements added to the meat. Foods rich in Omega-3, which include flaxseed oil, safflower oil, salmon and other cold water fishes help maintain healthy coats, appropriate weight, and keep fluid in the joints. For digestive purposes, Michelle and Larry add apple cider vinegar and yoghurt to the meat. Vitamin B, C, and E in powder or capsule form along with Alfalfa and sea salts offer many minerals and essential vitamins. Cathey gives her dogs a tablespoon of cod liver oil, or a Thorne Super EPA (essential fatty acid supplement) capsule -alternating them, one day, the other the next. When the need arises, Wendy and Victor use probiotics and Vitamin C to balance the immune system in times of stress. Renee and Evan make sure their puppies get some Vitamin C to support ligament growth, and are “more vigilant on adding extras to a bitch about to be bred, in whelp, or nursing a litter.”
On The Road
Whether it is traveling for vacation, showing, or performance trials these owners try and carry out the same regiment that they would when their dogs are dining from home. Jill takes a cooler full of frozen chicken when boarding — she says, “It makes all the other dogs jealous!” Wendy and Victor take a lot of camping trips and find it easy to pack a cooler full of meaty beef bones and raw chicken. When traveling from Canada to the U.S, Larry and Michelle buy the raw meat in the supermarkets and pre-pack most of the supplements. They are still hoping that Customs won’t be too curious as to what the bags of dry herbs and white powders are. Chris tries to bring her own water from home or buy bottled water for the dogs. Being on well water, without all the added chemicals of city water, she finds it easier on the dogs to have their own water. To help out a nervous traveler, she also packs some slippery elm and/or yogurt in case they get a loose stool. Cathey travels with a plug-in “refrigerator,” which she can plug in to the van, or at the motel to keep everything cold.
When sending a bitch to be bred, Renee and Evan will send frozen raw food to the stud dog owners - if they don’t feed raw themselves. They believe it is tremendously important to their overall health and is one area they won’t bend on.
Vet Support
Finding a vet that you are comfortable with and who is willing to work with you can be very beneficial. However, not all veterinarians are supportive of individuals who make the decision to go raw. Renee and Evan found themselves switching veterinarians. They found that their previous vet immediately blamed the diet for anything. They “mostly see the vet in the case of injuries or health testing for breeding and that’s it.” When Wendy and Victor lived in Colorado their vet was open to the idea of feeding raw, and in time he converted. Since moving to Minnesota they have found it more difficult to locate a good vet that supports raw but find it less necessary since they are comfortable with their choices and natural rearing philosophies.
Michelle and Larry actively sought out a holistic vet who has been great working with them to keep their Canaans “natural”. They also do annual titer testing to make sure of their immunity and to monitor any problems with their diet. Although Jill’s vet says he doesn’t’ like the bones - he would prefer that she ground them up – he hasn’t given her grief about the overall diet. He also says that her Canaans teeth are “picture perfect and clean as a whistle”. Chris’s vet in the States was very open to her decision to feed a natural diet. Seeing the improvement in the overall wellbeing of her dogs motivated her vet to switch her own dogs and now recommends a natural diet to some of her clients! Cathey says she has two vets: one is the “scientific vet” and the other is the “holistic vet.” Neither vet has a problem with the raw food diet. She also freely states that the area she lives in is “very much into the natural and organic lifestyle and philosophy for themselves and their dogs (but of course not raw food, as in raw meat for humans!)”
“YOUR DOG EATS RAW MEAT?” - Reactions from the community and Family
When the supermarkets in Georgia had a sale on meat, Chris was there to stock up! The usual comment was “Gee, when is the party?” When Chris replied that it was for the dogs people either rolled their eyes or were genuinely curious. Since moving to Australia, Chris says that raw feeding is a natural way of life: “Every butcher has their own “pet section” with a variety of meat and bones. Many of the vets don’t even stock kibble in their practices. There are companies that will deliver fresh meat to your door for the pets. The kibble section in the grocery store is about ½ the size of what you would see in the states. It’s very refreshing to see a non-kibble driven pet society.”
Like Chris, other raw feeders have found people’s curiosity peeked, especially when they see the shape and condition of their dogs. At first, Michelle and Larry felt a need to justify their decision to go raw to others: “Since most people take the “tried and true” method of feeding kibble we thought we needed to show both why we were doing it and how well the dogs were responding. Now 3 years later, it really doesn’t matter what people think. We have a high level of confidence in our decision and the proof is in the dogs. Both are happy, lively and very fit.”
Dionna and Robert have found people in general to be quite curious but at the same time very nervous about dealing with raw meat. Their children, 12 and 10, think it’s gross! Wendy and Victor’s boys are becoming raw feeder savvy. Wendy mentions the story of when “one of our pups might not be fed raw in their new home, and the boys became noticeably upset. They asked me if I had explained to the new owners why feeding raw is better, and if I told them how easy it was to do. To this day they still worry about that puppy because they see how happy the pups are when they eat raw in our home.” Chris’s son Ethan has no problems with the natural diet for the dogs. However he was a little upset a few years ago when “Guinan” raided their chicken coop to bring back a fresh kill for her litter of puppies. When Chris explained, “that’s a natural Canaan Dog” he accepted the loss of the chicken.
Contemplating the Raw Way?
These owners will tell you that making the decision to go raw has been worth the research, time and effort. Dionna says “It’s not that difficult. Just get set up and go for it. It also helps to have a mentor that you can ask questions of.” The first thing to do is to determine what results you would like to see in your dog and decide if a raw diet would give this to feed in this manner have to be explored. This is not an exercise that can be done with half measures. If you want to keep your dog healthy you must look at the time, cost and dedication required.
Saturday, July 4, 2009
Essential Oils Recipe
by Michelle Harrington
[From the Summer 2007 Canaan Club of Ontario Newsletter]
As a teenager I was the classic water rat. I worked in the evenings and on weekends as a swimming instructor and lifeguard and competed on the swim team. H20 was my life!I was always on the hunt for the latest hair and skin product to help alleviate the dryness caused from both pool and lake water.
One day my mother led me into the kitchen. Not one who was interested in baking, I was wondering if it was now the time I was to learn how to bake a pie. My mother handed me a big bottle of olive oil and told me to go to the sink. There, she drizzled the oil on my hair, massaged it thoroughly, and wrapped it in plastic wrap. She soothed oil on my hands and face and told me to go enjoy a book. Although the pages in my book became a bit saturated and the once a week wash cycle was less than pleasureable, the oil had restored brightness and comfort to my hair and skin the natural way.
Why "Oil up" your Canaan?
Essential fatty acids (EFAs) are vital nutrients that have an impact on both human and animals' bodies. EFAs aid in the functioning of the brain, cardiovascular and immune systems, gastro-intestional, and wound healing. From olive oil to flax seed oil, we can enhance the health of our canine companions inside and out, by introducing EFAs into their diets.
The following recipe is sure to bring a beautiful, soft and shiny coat on your Canaan. It does with ours. The recipe is from Andi Brown, author of the "The Whole Pet Diet: Eight Weeks to Great Health for Dogs and Cats.
Ingredients
5 ounces olive oil
1 ounce cod liver oil
1 ounce wheat germ oil
1 ounce flax seed oil
1 garlic clove, or 1 teaspoon garlic powder
1/2 teaspoon dried rosemary
Instructions
Combine all ingredients in a blender and pulse for 30 seconds. Pour into a dark glass bottle or jar. Store in the refrigerator for freshness. Mix 2 teaspoons into your Canaan's diet. The mixture will keep for two months.
[From the Summer 2007 Canaan Club of Ontario Newsletter]
As a teenager I was the classic water rat. I worked in the evenings and on weekends as a swimming instructor and lifeguard and competed on the swim team. H20 was my life!I was always on the hunt for the latest hair and skin product to help alleviate the dryness caused from both pool and lake water.
One day my mother led me into the kitchen. Not one who was interested in baking, I was wondering if it was now the time I was to learn how to bake a pie. My mother handed me a big bottle of olive oil and told me to go to the sink. There, she drizzled the oil on my hair, massaged it thoroughly, and wrapped it in plastic wrap. She soothed oil on my hands and face and told me to go enjoy a book. Although the pages in my book became a bit saturated and the once a week wash cycle was less than pleasureable, the oil had restored brightness and comfort to my hair and skin the natural way.
Why "Oil up" your Canaan?
Essential fatty acids (EFAs) are vital nutrients that have an impact on both human and animals' bodies. EFAs aid in the functioning of the brain, cardiovascular and immune systems, gastro-intestional, and wound healing. From olive oil to flax seed oil, we can enhance the health of our canine companions inside and out, by introducing EFAs into their diets.
The following recipe is sure to bring a beautiful, soft and shiny coat on your Canaan. It does with ours. The recipe is from Andi Brown, author of the "The Whole Pet Diet: Eight Weeks to Great Health for Dogs and Cats.
Ingredients
5 ounces olive oil
1 ounce cod liver oil
1 ounce wheat germ oil
1 ounce flax seed oil
1 garlic clove, or 1 teaspoon garlic powder
1/2 teaspoon dried rosemary
Instructions
Combine all ingredients in a blender and pulse for 30 seconds. Pour into a dark glass bottle or jar. Store in the refrigerator for freshness. Mix 2 teaspoons into your Canaan's diet. The mixture will keep for two months.
Friday, July 3, 2009
That'll Do Macc
Some of you have met our Canaan Dog, Maccabee. We started herding with Macc in 2004 with Sue Jewell. Macc has had his moments, both good and humourous, in the trial ring. We have always thought that he would be better if it was a full time job rather than a weekend hobby. The events of the past week would seem to point in that direction.
We have moved out to a quarter section in Alberta. We are still setting up what we hope will be a small sheep operation, but in the meantime we are helping to care for the 80 cow-calf pairs that are on the quarter south of us. The people that own the land reside in Calgary, and the rancher that owns the cows resides a couple of hours away. So we are monitoring water levels and checking fencing. And rounding up strays. This last task became apparent last Monday when I was driving up our road. There in the middle were 3 cows. So after I navigated my way around them and drove up to our place I called Macc over and we walked back to meet them. Bear in mind that his only experience with livestock to that point had been sheep. And he had only seen cows from the car. So I could see his attention prick up as he approached them. And they became very aware of him also. From what I gather these are cows that spend their life in the pasture, they are mated annually, and have little contact with anything other than other cows. So they are even skiddish of humans. As we approached them they begin to jostle each other and were becoming agitated. Now this is not something that will set Macc off, though. I have seen sheep calmly graze with him 10' away from them. He just stood there, tail down, with a slight head tilt watching these large creatures move around. After only a few minutes they began to calm enough that I started to approach them. This elicited a hasty retreat on their part to a more comfortable 20' distance. Talk about a sensitive flight zone.
So after about 20 minutes of each of us performing these dance steps I decided that we should see if we could move them in a direction that would get them back into the pasture. I called Macc to me and we started our first cattle drive. He trotted along one side of the road while I held the position on the other. We were able to deflect any detours that they contemplated and managed to get them up to the intersecting Township road. At this point I swung Macc out to the far right and we all executed a nice left hand turn. Now we had a much wider road to manage. Fortunately the cows moved to the north side along the fence. Unfortunately this was near many of the other cows. And as we later discovered a couple of bulls. Cows are pretty noisy when they get agitated. And this caused the others to become quite curious. So as we progressed down the road we gathered up quite an entourage. By the time we had reached the farm gate we had 40 - 50 cows on the other side of the fence waiting for us. This put a crimp in my plans because I had thought I could open the gate, send Macc around and push them back into the pasture. But now I had about 50 inmates looking for the Great Escape. All except the bull and cow in the back that were more interested in increasing the size the herd, if you get my drift.
Now I was faced with driving the cows back from the gate (which wouldn't open easily....I have since learned a quick and painless method to open such gates), and I was asking Macc to hold these 3 cows in position, which he was doing much better than I would ever had dreamed of seeing as I had thrown him into this escapade with very little forethought. But out of the corner of my eye I could see that the cows had other ideas. One by one they tested him by moving at him until they were only a couple of feet away. Then they backed up. Macc just stood there and watched them. Suddenly all three charged directly at him. He held his position until the last moment and then ducked to the side in a spirit of self preservation. And of course at that moment I managed to free the gate. So now I had to close it quickly, send Macc on a long out run to catch up to the fleeing bovines. Luckily some choice vegetation caught their fancy only a couple of hundred feet up the road. So while they were fixing their plates at the salad bar I sent Macc around and had him walk up on them. Now we have not performed these commands for a couple of years, so I was pretty much winging it. But trust a herding dog to know what is needed. He pushed them forward as I moved to the side and started back to the gate.
During all of this the other 50 or so cows (and bulls) were following along like they were at a golf tournament. And they were very quiet waiting for something to happen. The three strays started their bellowing again as Macc pushed them along, and then the rest of the gallery joined in. By the time I had reached the gate the whole gang was there to greet us. The first order of business was to open the gate, step through only to find that 2 bulls had taken up the lead position, swung a large stick at the bevy of bovines, and with Providence shining down, managed to move them back. Back on the road Macc had the cows locked to the fence and he was looking like he meant business this time. Any movement by them elicited a quick charge forward by him that put the bold bovine back in her place. As I exited the pasture I called out "Away To Me" and he swung around behind them. The cows surged forward, found the opening, and poured back into the pasture. Macc gave them a quick snort at the gate, sat and watched me close and fasten it, and then gave me a huge wag when I said "That'll Do". I couldn't have been more proud of him.
We have moved out to a quarter section in Alberta. We are still setting up what we hope will be a small sheep operation, but in the meantime we are helping to care for the 80 cow-calf pairs that are on the quarter south of us. The people that own the land reside in Calgary, and the rancher that owns the cows resides a couple of hours away. So we are monitoring water levels and checking fencing. And rounding up strays. This last task became apparent last Monday when I was driving up our road. There in the middle were 3 cows. So after I navigated my way around them and drove up to our place I called Macc over and we walked back to meet them. Bear in mind that his only experience with livestock to that point had been sheep. And he had only seen cows from the car. So I could see his attention prick up as he approached them. And they became very aware of him also. From what I gather these are cows that spend their life in the pasture, they are mated annually, and have little contact with anything other than other cows. So they are even skiddish of humans. As we approached them they begin to jostle each other and were becoming agitated. Now this is not something that will set Macc off, though. I have seen sheep calmly graze with him 10' away from them. He just stood there, tail down, with a slight head tilt watching these large creatures move around. After only a few minutes they began to calm enough that I started to approach them. This elicited a hasty retreat on their part to a more comfortable 20' distance. Talk about a sensitive flight zone.
So after about 20 minutes of each of us performing these dance steps I decided that we should see if we could move them in a direction that would get them back into the pasture. I called Macc to me and we started our first cattle drive. He trotted along one side of the road while I held the position on the other. We were able to deflect any detours that they contemplated and managed to get them up to the intersecting Township road. At this point I swung Macc out to the far right and we all executed a nice left hand turn. Now we had a much wider road to manage. Fortunately the cows moved to the north side along the fence. Unfortunately this was near many of the other cows. And as we later discovered a couple of bulls. Cows are pretty noisy when they get agitated. And this caused the others to become quite curious. So as we progressed down the road we gathered up quite an entourage. By the time we had reached the farm gate we had 40 - 50 cows on the other side of the fence waiting for us. This put a crimp in my plans because I had thought I could open the gate, send Macc around and push them back into the pasture. But now I had about 50 inmates looking for the Great Escape. All except the bull and cow in the back that were more interested in increasing the size the herd, if you get my drift.
Now I was faced with driving the cows back from the gate (which wouldn't open easily....I have since learned a quick and painless method to open such gates), and I was asking Macc to hold these 3 cows in position, which he was doing much better than I would ever had dreamed of seeing as I had thrown him into this escapade with very little forethought. But out of the corner of my eye I could see that the cows had other ideas. One by one they tested him by moving at him until they were only a couple of feet away. Then they backed up. Macc just stood there and watched them. Suddenly all three charged directly at him. He held his position until the last moment and then ducked to the side in a spirit of self preservation. And of course at that moment I managed to free the gate. So now I had to close it quickly, send Macc on a long out run to catch up to the fleeing bovines. Luckily some choice vegetation caught their fancy only a couple of hundred feet up the road. So while they were fixing their plates at the salad bar I sent Macc around and had him walk up on them. Now we have not performed these commands for a couple of years, so I was pretty much winging it. But trust a herding dog to know what is needed. He pushed them forward as I moved to the side and started back to the gate.
During all of this the other 50 or so cows (and bulls) were following along like they were at a golf tournament. And they were very quiet waiting for something to happen. The three strays started their bellowing again as Macc pushed them along, and then the rest of the gallery joined in. By the time I had reached the gate the whole gang was there to greet us. The first order of business was to open the gate, step through only to find that 2 bulls had taken up the lead position, swung a large stick at the bevy of bovines, and with Providence shining down, managed to move them back. Back on the road Macc had the cows locked to the fence and he was looking like he meant business this time. Any movement by them elicited a quick charge forward by him that put the bold bovine back in her place. As I exited the pasture I called out "Away To Me" and he swung around behind them. The cows surged forward, found the opening, and poured back into the pasture. Macc gave them a quick snort at the gate, sat and watched me close and fasten it, and then gave me a huge wag when I said "That'll Do". I couldn't have been more proud of him.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)